1. Choose flavor of ice cream and pick cookies to match.
2. Use a large spoon to scoop a slightly softened scoop of ice cream onto one cookie and press the ice cream out to the edges.
3. Press dry toppings onto the ice cream scoop, and spread any soft toppings onto the second cookie.
4. Close the sandwich with the second cookie and roll the edges into a final dry topping if desired.
Suggested Flavor Combinations:
1. Vanilla ice cream + chocolate cookies + fudge + chopped maraschino cherries + chopped chocolate or chocolate sprinkles
2. Mint chip ice cream + chocolate cookies + fudge + chocolate sprinkles
3. Vanilla ice cream + chocolate cookies + instant espresso powder + chopped chocolate
4. Chocolate ice cream + peanut butter cookies + fudge
5. Vanilla ice cream + chocolate cookies + peanut butter + chopped peanuts
6. Chocolate, vanilla or chocolate chip ice cream + chocolate chip cookies + peanut butter + chopped peanuts
7. Strawberry ice cream + sugar cookies + strawberry jam + rainbow sprinkle
1. The ice cream should be just lightly softened, not rock hard. If it's too soft, it will start to melt and if it's too hard, it will be difficult to mound evenly on the cookie, and could break the cookie.
2. Spread the sauce on one cookie, and the ice cream on the other. It's difficult to spread the ice cream on a slippery surface.
3. If dipping the sandwich in melted chocolate, it's best to freeze the sandwich until it's very firm before dipping, or the ice cream will start to melt into the chocolate. Use a melted chocolate bar or chocolate chips, something that will harden up. Avoid hot fudge as it will stay sticky.